Wheatley Grove, Ben Rhydding: at least 125 homes on Green Belt fieldsWheatley Grove: 125 homes Comments close 5pm Mon 30 Nov 2026
Start my response
Ben Rhydding · Bradford Local Plan consultation

Wheatley Grove: at least 125 homes on the fields above Ben Rhydding

The sloping fields off Wheatley Grove, on the southern edge of Ben Rhydding, are housing site H383 in Bradford's draft Local Plan. The plan would take the 7.17 hectares out of the Green Belt and sets a minimum of 125 homes. Comments made now go to an independent Inspector.

Mon30 Nov5pm

That is the final moment to comment on the plan. Bradford will not accept anything sent afterwards.

Outlines drawn from the map data the council publishes with the plan. The official boundary is on Bradford's policies map.
750comments on this site in 2021

Objected before? You need to respond again.

Wheatley Grove was in the council's 2021 draft plan as a site for 130 homes, and the council's consultation portal lists 750 comments on it from that consultation. This is a new stage of consultation. To be considered now, you need to respond again, even if you objected before.

Once comments close, Bradford's Full Council decides whether to send the plan for examination "together with all the Regulation 19 representations", in the council's words. That meeting is scheduled for 9 December 2026. The Inspector then examines the plan with the comments made at this stage.

Sources: comments on the 2021 Wheatley Grove site, Bradford's Local Plan questions and answers, Executive report para 2.133.

18days until comments close, at 5pm on Monday 30 November.
125homes as a minimum, across 7.17 hectares taken out of the Green Belt
1new access, from Wheatley Grove. Not from Ben Rhydding Drive, says the site entry.
The site at a glance

Wheatley Grove: what is proposed?

The council's draft Local Plan allocates Land off Wheatley Grove, site H383, for at least 125 homes, at a net density of 35 homes per hectare. The land would be removed from the Green Belt, and the council expects the homes between 2030 and 2035.

The council's site entry says the land is almost completely covered with grassland habitat and contains areas of woodland protected by a Tree Preservation Order. When the site was proposed in 2021, the council described a "sloping field with central copse and trees on boundaries" and recorded a public right of way through it.

The site entry says access would need to be a new one from Wheatley Grove, and that access is not considered available from Ben Rhydding Drive. It also asks for homes to go across the northern edge of the site, away from the more elevated land to the south.

An allocation does not grant planning permission, and a developer would still have to apply. But it establishes the principle that housing is appropriate here, which makes the location much harder to challenge once the plan is adopted.

The question is not whether Bradford needs homes. It is whether the evidence supports at least 125 of them here, on sloping Green Belt grassland that the council's own nature recovery measure marks for restoration, reached by one new access from Wheatley Grove.

A wide grassy field with mature oak trees on the left and houses among trees in the distance, under a clear sky
The field above the housing at Ben Rhydding, inside site H383, June 2023. (Bill Boaden / CC BY-SA 2.0)
Reference
H383, Land off Wheatley Grove
Minimum homes
125
Gross area
7.17 hectares
Current status
Greenfield, in the Green Belt
Road access
New access from Wheatley Grove
Expected delivery
2030 to 2035

Taken from site entry H383 and Policy IL1 of the Publication Draft. The 2021 description is from the Preferred Options draft, site IL1/H.

Ilkley's share

From 280 homes to 593

The 2021 draft asked Ilkley to find new sites for 280 homes. This draft allocates 593, across four sites. Wheatley Grove was proposed both times, then for 130 homes and now for 125.

The 2026 sites are Hadfield Farm (256 homes), East of Wheatley Lane (200), Wheatley Grove (125) and Stockeld Road (12). With 208 homes on new sites in Addingham, that is around 800 new homes for the two towns, while the council's Executive report says there are "no showstopper infrastructure issues which cannot be mitigated or planned for".

East of Wheatley Lane, site H385, a minimum of 200 homes, lies a short way to the north, so both sites would add homes to Ben Rhydding.

Ilkley's new housing sites

Homes on each proposed site, 2021 Preferred Options draft compared with the 2026 Publication Draft.

2026 draft

Hadfield Farm, 256 East of Wheatley Lane, 200 Wheatley Grove, 125 Stockeld Road, 12

2021 draft

Coutances Way, 155 Wheatley Grove, 130 Skipton Road East, 20 Stockeld Road, 9
Before the deadline

Making a response count

  1. 1Point to H383

    Your comment should name Land off Wheatley Grove, H383, which sits in the Ilkley section of the plan under Policy IL1.

  2. 2Say what fails

    Explain, in your own way, which soundness question the site does not satisfy. A unique response is worth more than a copied one.

  3. 3Ask for an outcome

    Request removal, or a smaller site kept to the lower ground and released only once access, school places and GP capacity are dealt with.

  4. 4Keep your voice

    If you would like to speak at the examination hearings, say so. Anyone asking for a change can.

OnlineUse the council's comment form on bradford.oc2.uk, which asks you to register.
EmailSend it to planning.policy@bradford.gov.uk. The response builder on this page sets that up for you.
PostLocal Plan Team, City of Bradford MDC, 4th Floor, Britannia House, Bradford BD1 1HX, arriving before the deadline.

Late or anonymous comments are not accepted, so give your name and address. The council is running online information sessions on Microsoft Teams from 5pm to 6pm on Thursday 12 and Wednesday 18 November, which you can book by emailing the address above.

Grounds for objection

Where the case for H383 falls short

An Inspector checks the plan against four questions. Has it been positively prepared? Is it justified? Will it be effective? Does it follow national policy? Each point here names the question it raises.

Question: effective?

One way in, from Wheatley Grove

01
One new accessfrom Wheatley Grove for at least 125 homes. "Access is not considered available from Ben Rhydding Drive."

The council's site entry says access to the site "is available from Wheatley Grove, which would require a new access", and that access is not considered available from Ben Rhydding Drive. On the council's own account, the homes would depend on that new access. Yet the council's transport mitigation is aimed at major economic growth locations and strategic junctions, and its Transport Assessment singles out no junction in Ilkley for mitigation.

Question to putWhat evidence shows that a new access from Wheatley Grove can safely serve at least 125 homes, and what happens to the allocation if it cannot?
Question: national policy?

Green Belt on rising ground

A large bare oak tree in a grassy field on a grey winter day, with sheep grazing and houses among trees beyond
A track up the field off Ben Rhydding Drive that once led to the Hydro, inside the site, December 2020. (Stephen Craven / CC BY-SA 2.0)
02
1.17%of Bradford district's Green Belt is released through the plan

National policy permits Green Belt boundaries to move only in exceptional circumstances, with as little harm as possible. The council's own landscape advice treats this land with care. It places the site in the Wharfedale Rolling Enclosed Pasture landscape type, and says development "should be located across the northern edge of the site, away from the more elevated extents to the south". It asks for hedgerows, copses of trees and stone boundary walls to be kept.

Question to putWhat did the Green Belt and landscape evidence find about harm on this sloping land, and how would at least 125 homes fit on the northern edge alone?
Question: national policy?

Grassland, bats and moorland birds

03
Almost all grasslandwith protected woodland, in a bat alert area, and mostly in Zone B for the South Pennine Moors, says the site entry

A small strip along the western edge is in Zone A of the South Pennine Moors Special Protection Area, where no residential development must take place. Most of the site is in Zone B, where proposals must assess impacts on foraging habitat used by the protected moorland birds. The land is almost completely grassland, with woodland covered by a Tree Preservation Order, and lies in a bat alert area. The council's Local Nature Recovery Strategy measure for this land is to "restore and enhance existing species-rich grasslands". The ecological survey that would test all this is only required once someone applies for planning permission.

Question to putWhat ecological evidence supports allocating this land now, and how does building on it fit the council's own nature recovery measure for the grassland?
Question: effective?

School places and GPs

04
About 800 homeson new sites in Ilkley and Addingham alone (593 and 208)

Bradford's own school place planning has one secondary school, Ilkley Grammar, in its Ilkley planning area. When this site was proposed in 2021, the council's sustainability appraisal said "access to both primary and secondary schools is somewhat limited due to distance", and that residents may need to travel up to 2km for services and amenities. The council's position now is that there are "no showstopper infrastructure issues which cannot be mitigated or planned for".

Question to putHow many primary and secondary school places, and how much GP capacity, will be funded, and will they be ready before people move in?
Question: effective?

Open space and play

05
Play, parks, allotmentsall listed as deficient in Ilkley in the council's Open Space Assessment

The site entry says the council's Open Space Assessment "highlights deficiencies in the provision of allotments, children's play areas, open land in settlements and parks and gardens within the settlement", and that new developments need amenity greenspace. In 2021 the council recorded a public right of way through the site. National policy's Golden Rules for Green Belt release include accessible green space.

Question to putHow would the existing shortfalls in play space, parks and allotments be met, and how would the public right of way and open green space here be kept?
Straight from the site entry

The council's own notes on H383

Bradford's entry for the site lists these requirements and constraints. Each line on the right is quoted word for word from the Publication Draft, including the points the council makes in the site's favour.

Noticed bats, birds or other wildlife on or near the site? Log the sighting with West Yorkshire Ecology, the county's records centre. Ecologists draw on those records when they assess land for development.

  • Access to the site is available from Wheatley Grove, which would require a new access. Access is not considered available from Ben Rhydding Drive.Highways
  • A small part of the site along its western edge falls within Zone A (Urban Edge Effects) where no residential development must take place.Moorland birds
  • The site is almost completely covered with grassland habitat and contains areas with TPO woodland. The site is also within a bat alert area.Ecology
  • The site is identified in the LNRS with the preferred measure G1_M03: Restore and enhance existing species-rich grasslands.Nature recovery
  • Development should be located across the northern edge of the site, away from the more elevated extents to the south.Landscape
  • Where existing stone boundary walls exist, these should also be incorporated to ensure that this element of the rural character of the site is retained.Character
  • It is likely that the development of the site can be undertaken without harm to the significance or setting of the nearby designated heritage assets.Heritage
  • Any FRA should include for a drainage strategy which should investigate ground conditions for infiltration SuDS suitability.Drainage
What the council says

Know the other side before you write

Bradford must plan for at least 33,669 homes by 2043. Around 70% go to the city, and the council says brownfield land alone cannot meet the need. The supply only beats the target by about 192 homes, so an Inspector will expect any site removed to be replaced somewhere.

For Ilkley, Policy IL1 focuses housing growth on "limited infill, and settlement boundary extensions to western and eastern edges with services and facilities within reasonable walking distance". Policy HO4 expects at least 50% affordable housing on land released from the Green Belt in Ilkley, unless that is shown to be unviable. So a response asking for H383 to be removed or reduced on the evidence will carry more weight than one rejecting the plan outright.

Your response

Answer a few questions and get a draft to edit

The builder turns your answers into a first draft written in the first person. Edit it as much as you like, then send it from your own email. Nothing reaches the council unless you send it. If you wrote in 2021, this is the time to write again.

1Who you are

Bradford only accepts responses that give a name and address.

2What concerns you

Pick the points you care about most. A focused response is often stronger than one that covers everything.

3Your own knowledge

Optional. A detail only a local person would know is often the most persuasive part of a response.

0 / 800
4The outcome you want
Private by design. The draft is assembled on your own device. What you type stays in this browser tab and is never saved by this site. We keep an anonymous tally of which boxes get ticked. Bear in mind that the council publishes names alongside the comments it receives.

Your draft will show here

Fill in the four steps and press Prepare my response. Because the draft is built from your own answers, each one comes out different.

Once you have sent it

Help more neighbours respond

Many people who wrote in 2021 may not know they need to write again. A personal response from each of them counts for more than a name on a list.

Pass it on

Share this page with the people next door, on your street or in your local groups.

About this page

Local residents put this page together, with help from West Ilkley Residents. It is not published by Bradford Council and is independent of it. The figures are drawn from the council's own documents, all listed below, and any error you point out will be put right.